JeetoBharat
All current affairs

Judicial Accountability and Resignation: Legal Implications for Removal Proceedings

GS2

The resignation of a High Court judge renders ongoing parliamentary removal proceedings legally moot, as the office itself ceases to exist upon the resignation taking effect.

The constitutional process for the removal of a judge of the Supreme Court or a High Court, as mandated under Article 124(4) and Article 217(1)(b) of the Indian Constitution, is a rigorous mechanism involving an address by each House of Parliament supported by a special majority. However, a significant legal question arises when a judge resigns while such proceedings are pending: does the parliamentary inquiry continue, or does it become functus officio?

Recent communications from Justice Yashwant Varma to the Lok Sabha Secretariat clarify this issue by invoking the principle that resignation from a constitutional office takes effect by its own force upon submission. Citing established legal precedents, including the landmark 1978 Supreme Court judgment, it is argued that the removal process is fundamentally tied to the existence of the office holder. Once a judge has demitted office via resignation, the primary objective of the motion—the removal from service—is rendered redundant. There remains no incumbent to be removed, and therefore, the jurisdictional basis for the parliamentary committee or the House to proceed with an inquiry evaporates.

From a constitutional perspective, this highlights a critical distinction between judicial independence and accountability. While the 'removal' process is a tool for maintaining probity in the judiciary, the act of resignation serves as an immediate cessation of the official relationship between the individual and the State. Consequently, any continuation of parliamentary proceedings post-resignation would not only lack a legal subject matter but could also be interpreted as an encroachment upon the personal liberty of the individual who is no longer a public servant subject to that specific disciplinary mechanism. This scenario underscores the procedural limitations of legislative oversight and the importance of strictly interpreting the scope of constitutional powers.

Continue reading — free with login

JeetoBharat publishes daily UPSC current affairs mapped to the Mains syllabus. Log in to read full articles.

Log in to read full article

No credit card required. Free registered users get unlimited access.

This article was curated using AI. While we strive for accuracy, please verify critical facts from official sources.

More UPSC Current Affairs

View month archive →